The war we opposed and the soldiers we failed to see.

This blog is the first of a three-part series exploring who gets heard, who gets silenced, who carries the cost and who avoids responsibility.

                                                              Image source 

When I was asked to run a World Peace Day workshop for young people, I started with this question. How do we disagree with someone without turning them into an enemy?

Wars have many causes, including power, territory, resources, fear and ideology. They become more likely when leaders stop listening, stop looking for common ground and decide to resolve their differences through violence.

I built the workshop around four skills: curiosity, creativity, collaboration and communication. These skills help us listen to different perspectives, explore possibilities, work with others and explain our ideas when we disagree.

I’ve spent years learning how these skills contribute to effective negotiation. Knowing what you want is only part of it. You also need to understand what the other person wants, what they fear, what they value and how the situation looks from their perspective. You cannot walk into a room armed with assumptions and expect to find common ground.

As I prepared the workshop, I began thinking about war and the Australia in which I grew up.

I was born in 1956. Australia entered the Vietnam War while I was a child and withdrew as I was approaching university. Young men only a few years older than me had their futures decided by numbered marbles drawn from a barrel, what became known as the ‘death lottery’. If their birthday was selected, they could be conscripted for two years of full-time military service and sent to Vietnam. Yet I remember remarkably little discussion about the war at home.

I wanted to hear how people a few years older than me remembered that period. I write living histories. I ask people about their experiences, listen to their perspectives and help them tell their stories.

I’m particularly interested in people who can discuss difficult and contentious issues respectfully, even when they disagree. My neighbours Robin and Jenny are very good at this. They examine what they believed at the time, what informed those beliefs and what they understand differently today. They’re prepared to question their own assumptions and listen to people whose experiences differ from theirs.

Watching Robin and Jenny discuss difficult issues gives me examples of the respectful disagreement I encourage young people to practise.

Both belong to the generation that came of age during the Vietnam War. Both opposed it and have spent their lives thinking deeply about politics, justice and the society we create together. A conversation with either of them can send me home with enough ideas to occupy my mind for days. Having both of them at the table on the same morning was a real treat.

Robin and her husband, Ron, left Australia in 1968 and returned in 1973. Much of her understanding of the war came through the people she met.

Before leaving Australia, they lived two doors from a young barrister involved in defending William White, one of the first Australians to publicly resist conscription. Through him, Robin learnt more about the people challenging Australia’s involvement in Vietnam and the consequences they faced.

Later, while living in Canada, Robin and Ron became friends with American draft resisters at university. These young men could not return to the United States without risking arrest. One lost his father and could not go home for the funeral.

Robin remembers learning in psychology that one of the most effective ways to challenge a stereotype is to get to know someone from the group being stereotyped. Once you know someone personally, you begin to recognise how much individuals differ from the assumptions made about them.

“Once you know someone as an individual, that person often fails to fit the stereotype. The certainty begins to weaken,” Robin told me.

I could see the relevance to my workshop. Curiosity requires us to be prepared to discover things that challenge what we already believe.

As Robin explained, “To understand an adversary, you have to become curious about how that person sees the world. You have to learn about their culture and put yourself in their position.”

Jenny started university in 1968, a year of student protests and considerable confidence among young people that they could change the world. Her generation believed the adults had made a dreadful mess of things and that young people were going to fix it.

Vietnam dominated university life. Students knew young men whose birthdays might be selected in the conscription ballot. Draft resisters were regarded as courageous, and thousands joined the moratorium marches. Jenny was among them.

She argued with her father, whose generation had gone to war, stood behind the Australian flag and felt proud to serve. Jenny’s generation questioned whether Vietnam was comparable with those earlier wars. They opposed Australia’s involvement and challenged the conscription of young men through a lottery.

The protests were part of a much wider period of social change. Young Australians were challenging the White Australia policy, censorship, apartheid and the country’s cultural conservatism.

Jenny attended only one rugby match in her life. She paid to enter so she could join a protest against the touring South African Springboks.

She describes herself as an eternal Pollyanna optimist. The election of the Whitlam government seemed to confirm that a more open and hopeful Australia was emerging.

The period politicised much of her generation. It taught them that governments could be questioned and authority challenged. It influenced how Jenny voted and how she understood her responsibilities as a citizen.

Then Jenny acknowledged something about her attitude at the time that she now regrets. She gave little thought to what Australian soldiers were experiencing in Vietnam or what happened when they returned home. She opposed the war so strongly that she wondered why the soldiers had gone. Why had they not objected? Why had they not refused?

Looking back, she recognises how little sympathy or understanding she had for them.

Many had no choice. They were conscripted, sent into horrific circumstances and returned to a country in which their service was controversial. Government support was inadequate, and some returning veterans encountered hostility from people who held them responsible for the political decisions that had sent them to war.

Jenny remains convinced that the Vietnam War was unjustified and Australia should never have taken part. Her compassion for the veterans does not require her to change that position.

“Opposing the war should never have meant withdrawing compassion from those who endured it,” she told me.

She can recognise that the war was wrong while acknowledging that the young men sent to fight it deserved care, understanding and respect.

“Questioning authority and caring about people must go together.”

Jenny also told me about a man she had known since primary school who was sent to Vietnam. He was badly wounded in a minefield explosion and spent months recovering in hospital. He later became a leader in the Oberon RSL, supporting veterans, widows and others in his community.

Growing up and working in agriculture has taught me what happens when we continually allow others to speak on behalf of the people directly affected by decisions. It’s one reason I place so much importance on hearing from people with firsthand experience.

After listening to Jenny and Robin, I wanted to speak with someone who had been sent to Vietnam.

I was conscious that asking someone about their military service could bring back painful memories. I also wanted to understand how a young man who had accepted his call-up viewed that decision nearly six decades later, and what he thought about the way returning veterans were treated.

I asked Jenny whether she would approach her childhood friend and find out if he was prepared to talk with me.

I would leave it entirely to him to decide what he wanted to discuss, what he preferred to keep private and whether he wanted his experiences published.

I was particularly interested in what he believed people of my generation, and those who followed, should understand about being sent to Vietnam, returning to Australia and living with the consequences.

In the workshop at Cowra, I encouraged young people to question their assumptions, listen to different perspectives and consider whose experiences were missing from a discussion.

Having spoken with Jenny and Robin, it was time for me to do the same.

My memories of American soldiers during the Vietnam War

Our family hosted American soldiers who came to Australia for a week’s rest and recreation leave from Vietnam. We were among more than 2,500 Australian families who registered to welcome American servicemen into their homes during the war.

We certainly didn’t discuss the war when they arrived. They joined in whatever we were doing as a family, and life carried on much as usual.

At the time, I was showing horses. One of the American soldiers was an experienced horseman, so I spent much of his week with us enjoying our shared interest in horses. I remember that connection far more clearly than anything about his military service.

American servicemen were generally unable to return to the United States during their ordinary rest and recreation leave. Instead, they travelled to places such as Australia, Japan and Hawaii.

Australian Vietnam veteran Bill Wilcox recalls that the Americans weren’t allowed home because there were concerns they might refuse to return to Vietnam. The restrictions are documented, although I haven’t been able to confirm whether that was the official reason.

While young Australians were protesting against the war and others were being conscripted to fight, our family was welcoming American soldiers into our home. We knew they had come from Vietnam, yet we spent our time together doing the ordinary things that made up our daily lives.

For one week, a young American soldier and an Australian girl had horses in common.